Friday, October 07, 2005

Thoughts on Courtney Love

I try to avoid even thinking about Courtney Love, but my ill-advised subscription to Spin magazine made that impossible with the latest issue. The list (and it seems they focus more on lists than articles these days) this time was the 10 (or 20 or whatever) Most Influential Artists of the Last 20 years. And surprise, surprise, the gentle and eloquent Ms. Love is on the list! My first reaction was outrage. Then I began thinking maybe they had a good reason. Maybe they chose her because she killed Kurt Cobain, securing Nevermind's legacy from the irreparable harm that a long string of In Utero-quality records surely would have done. After all, Cobain's death was obviously so moving to a whole generation that many of us are convinced that even In Utero was brilliant. Had he not died young, we may have even looked back and questioned Nevermind. But not now. Not after Courtney killed him (or had him killed or whatever). So in that sense, Courtney Love really was influential. I never realized it until Spin made me think about it.

Then I read the accomanying interview. I should have stuck with outrage.

4 Comments:

Blogger Metal Mark said...

Unfortunately way too many people thought that In Utero was brilliant before Kurt's death. I still have nightmares about my college room mate singing songs from this album at like 7:00 AM and waking me up. Maybe Courtney Love did contribute in the way you outlined. So her major musical contribution is a little like Hawkwind's greatest accomplishment which was that they booted Lemmy out so he was able to form Motorhead.

4:40 PM  
Blogger Ms. Amanda Tate said...

I have no brilliant musical insights to offer; instead, I am cracking up about your tone toward Courtney. I've known for a LONG time that you are not a fan of hers . . . so this entire post (for me, anyway) was just dripping with intolerance. Very funny.

7:08 AM  
Blogger David Amulet said...

One must remember that Ms. Love was an early vocalist for Faith No More--before the band had mainstream success, of course.

I still don't see the talent in that woman that the wise "critics" see ...

-- david

8:26 PM  
Blogger Bar L. said...

interesting. I have no comment on Courtney because I try to follow the adage "if you have nothing nice to say keep your mouth shut"

11:50 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home